testata inforMARE
Cerca
02 April 2025 - Year XXIX
Independent journal on economy and transport policy
04:18 GMT+2
LinnkedInTwitterFacebook
This page has been automatically translated by
Original news
the Council of State assigns the property of Toremar to Tuscany di Navigazione and it removes Moby
Overturned the sentence first degree of the REGIONAL ADMINISTRATIVE COURT on the privatization of the navigation company
January 19, 2015

The Council of State, with sentence that we publish below, has received the resource of Tuscany di Navigazione against Region Tuscany and Moby for the privatization of the Toremar, company of the Tuscany Region that work marine services between the Tuscan ports of Livorno, Piombino and Santo Stefano Port and the islands of the Tuscan archipelago and whose capital in 2011 was conferred with public contest to the shipowning group Moby di Vincenzo Onorato ( on 5 May 2011). In the 2012 Regional administrative court for the Tuscany it had rejected the advanced resource from Tuscany di Navigazione for being excluded from the contest procedure as, having also advanced the economically more favorable offer, in the technical offer it had proposed an additional series of race regarding when tax from the contest ban.

Now Tuscany di Navigazione, that it is constituted by the network formed by Salvatore Lauro, Franco Del Giudice, Tiziano Nocentini and Vincenzo Gorgoglione, will have to decide if to accept the acquisition of the Toremar. It is possible that Moby or the Tuscany Region, or from both, advances in alternative a compensation proposal.

The city council member to the transports of the Tuscany Region, Vincenzo Ceccarelli, taking note of the decision of the Administrative court of second degree that has overturned the sentence first degree of the REGIONAL ADMINISTRATIVE COURT, has specified that the sentence of the Council of State "in no way will be able to affect the continuity of the contractual relationship between Toremar and Region in relation to the public service that the company carries out and will continue to carry out. This clarified - it has added - our offices is already deepening the content of the sentence in order to understand as applying it at best".






N. 00083/2015REG.PROV.COLL.
N. 03189/2012 REG.RIC.

ITALIAN REPUBLIC
IN THE NAME OF ITALIAN PEOPLE

The Council of State
in jurisdictional center (Section Fifth)
it has pronounced anticipates

SENTENCE

on the resource number of general registry 3189 of 2012, proposed they give:
Tuscany di Navigazione Srl, represented and defended from avv.ti Marcello Vignolo, Massimo Massa and Mario Sanino, with address which elected near Antonia De Angelis in Rome, via Portuense, 104;

against

Tuscany region, represented and defended from the avv. Lucia Bora and Luciana Caso, with address which elected near Marcello Cecchetti in Rome, to the way Antonio Mordini, n. 14;
Moby Spa, represented and defended from avv.ti Giuseppe Pericu, Sergio Massimiliano Sambri and Maurizio Mengassini, with address which elected near the Grimaldi study in Rome, to the way Pinciana, n. 25;

for the reform

of the sentence of the T.A.R. TUSCANY - FLORENCE: SECTION the n. 00414/2012, been profitable between the parts, concerning Toremar privatization spa and confidence services publics of marine cabotage

Seen the resource in appeal and relative the attached ones;
Seen the certificates of incorporation in judgment of Tuscany Region and Moby Spa;
Seen the defensive memories;
Visas all the actions of the cause;
Reporter in the public audience of the day 21 October 2014 the Cons. Francesco Caringella and hearings for the parts lawyers Massimo Massa, Maurizio Mengassini and Marcello Cecchetti, on delegation of avv.ti Lucia Bora and Luciana Caso;
Considered and considered in fact and right how much follows.


FACT and RIGHT

1. With the sentence in epigraph the Regional administrative court for the Tuscany has rejected to the resource proposed from adverse Tuscany di Navigazione s.r.l the provision of exclusion from the procedure of contest finalized to the privatization of the enterprise of regional navigation Toremar s.p.a, to adjudicate itself with the criterion of the economically more favorable offer on a level with criteria that previewed the attribution of ten for services additional points, of seventy points for the quality of the used ship and of twenty points for the economic offer.
To the contest the offers of the Moby S.p.a and the Tuscany di Navigazione S.r.l. were admitted.
To the outcome of the appraisal lead from the Commission the offer formulated from Tuscany di Navigazione s.r.l turned out to be the economically more favorable offer, with the allocation of 87,28 points against the 70,92 points attributed to the Moby s.p.a.
The contracting out station arranged however to the exclusion of the Tuscany Navigation as a result of the reply of a dissonance between the economic offer and that technique with which an additional number of race various from that tax in binding way from the contest law was offered.
In support of the espulsiva determination came, in particular, found a difference between the additional services declared from Tuscany di Navigazione S.r.l in technical offer and the offered nautical miles, circumstance this, second the Commission, not susceptible of regularization through a mere operation of I recalculate and that it would have, instead, necessarily involved a reformulation of the same offer.
With the appeal action the Tuscany Navigation contests the arguments mails to foundation of the decisum.
They resist the Region Tuscany and Moby S.p.a.
The parts have entrusted to the warehouse of appropriate memories the ulterior illustration of the respective defensive theses.
2. The appeal is founded.
2.1. It must be moved from the consideration that, in force of the discipline of contest, the integral offer of race additional a not necessary part of the offer. Be, therefore, of a finalized optional member to the attainment of an ulterior score, pairs to a maximum of ten points, regarding the score being up to the indefectible members dates from the quality of the ship and necessary relative the economic offer to the race based on the exercise program.
From the premise of the optional characterization of this segment of the offer it must be drawn, based on principles of the favor partecipationis and of conservation of the legal transactions, the corollary second which the relative defects to such member affect the attribution of the additional score without ridondare on admissibility of the basic offer self-sufficient person and in compliance with the norm of contest. If of single species in appearance the elimination of the race additional implies the necessity of a not permissible reformulation of the economic offer. Rapportando the migliatico price to the race obligatory and those optional ones turns out in fact possible to characterize, according to a merely arithmetical operation that does not imply some substitution to the will of the relative competitor to the migliatico price and the economic value of the two members of the exercise program, obligatory relative the economic offer to the race. The goodness of such offer after all is not scratched, in homage to the useful brocard for useless not vitiatur, from the exclusion of the optional member of the technical offer and its connected economic valorization.
3. To the stregua of the considerations that precede the appeal must be received.
The expenses follow the rule of the soccombenza.


P.Q.M.

The Council of State in jurisdictional center (Section Fifth)
definitively pronouncing on the appeal, as in proposed epigraph, it receives it and, for the effect, in reform of the named sentence it receives the resource first degree and it cancels, in with the consequent provisions, the provision of exclusion of the Tuscany Navigations. Sentence the intimata administration to arrange the award of the procedure, to the conditions in motivation exposed, in favour of the appellant, against the necessary control of subjective requirement.
Sentence the Region Tuscany and Moby s.p.a to the payment, in favour of the appellant part, of the expenses of liquid judgment that in the total measure of euro 20,000//00 (ventimila//00).
It orders that sentence anticipates is executed by the administrative authority.
So decided in Rome in the Council Chamber of the day 21 October 2014 with the participation of the magistrates:
Alessandro Pajno, President
Francesco Caringella, Councilman, Drafter
Carlo Saltelli, Councilman
Nicola Gaviano, Councilman
Fabio Franconiero, Councilman


THE DRAFTER


THE PRESIDENT

DEPOSITED IN SECRETARIAT
The 16/01/2015
THE SECRETARY
(Art. 89, Co. 3, cod. proc. amm.)
›››News file
FROM THE HOME PAGE
Public interest declared for MSC, Neri and Lorenzini's project for a new container terminal in Livorno
Leghorn
The documentation requested by the company has been sent to Terminal Investment Limited
Slight annual growth in freight traffic in Italian ports driven by containers
Slight annual growth in freight traffic in Italian ports driven by containers
Rome
In the container segment, the strong increase in transhipments offset the decline in imports and exports
Turkey's Desan Shipyard in talks to take over Mangalia shipyard
Bucharest
The Tuzla plant is much smaller than the Romanian one
Six international shipping associations present a guide to planning safe navigation
London
The purpose is to detect, avoid, deter, delay and report attacks and incidents on ships.
TUI awards Fincantieri contract for two new cruise ships for Marella Cruises
Hanover/Trieste
Deliveries are scheduled for 2030 and 2032
ESPO urges EU and Member States to allocate funds to decarbonise ships and ports
Brussels
Earmarking Innovation Fund proceeds to stimulate demand for clean marine fuels
China Antitrust Launches Investigation into Hutchison Ports' Panama Terminal Sale
Beijing/Hong Kong
Panama Ports Company operates the Balboa and Cristobal ports
PSA posts annual revenue growth, but profits fall
Singapore
Sharp increase in operating costs across the board
Temporary Port Labor Supply Company in Cagliari Extended for Another 18 Months
Cagliari
In 2024, cargo traffic in Chinese seaports grew by +3.5%
Beijing
Increase of +6.9% in traffic with foreign countries. In the first two months of 2025, 1.75 billion tons were moved (+1.6%)
Chinese container maker CIMC posts bumper 2024
In February, freight traffic in the port of Genoa fell by -4.4% and in Savona-Vado it increased by +24.5%
Genoa
Cruise and ferry passenger decline
ICS, Trump's proposed measures against Chinese ships risk having significant unwanted consequences, even for the US
Washington
Strong opposition to their introduction also expressed by the WSC
Intercargo, international measures for decarbonisation of shipping must be simple and clear
London
Gkonis: Must not compromise operational efficiency and smooth global transport of essential goods
Port of Barcelona invests 124 million to develop sustainable fuel traffic
Barcelona
Construction of three new moorings at Moll de l'Energia
In 2024, freight traffic in the port of Catania began to grow again. A decline in Augusta
In 2024, freight traffic in the port of Catania began to grow again. A decline in Augusta
Augusta
A total of 7.9 million and 23.0 million tons of cargo were handled
In 2024, the terminal operator HHLA recorded record revenues with a growth of +10.5%
Hamburg
Profit after taxes amounted to 56.4 million euros (+33.1%)
Launch of a public consultation for the updating of the PRPs of the ports of Genoa and Savona-Vado
Genoa
The involvement of territorial, economic and social communities is foreseen
ITU, ICAO and IMO highlight risks to maritime and air transport caused by attacks on satellite communications
Geneva/Montreal/London
London Government presents its strategy for decarbonising maritime transport
London
The measures for ports will be defined after a public consultation that will take place in the coming months
For security, military ships are not enough, merchant ships are also essential
London
TUI in talks with shipyards for two new cruise ships for Marella
Hanover
Slots available starting from the 2031 financial year
ANESCO, with the Port Employment Centers, accidents have decreased in the three main Spanish ports
Madrid
67% reduction in lost work days per year
Filt, Fit and Uilt, no to the transformation from "article 18" to "16" of the Livorno port company LTM
Leghorn
Unions ask port authority to block proliferation of new economic entities
Last year Fincantieri recorded record revenues and new orders
Last year Fincantieri recorded record revenues and new orders
Trieste
Folgiero: the first fruits of our strategy and industrial vision have been harvested
COSCO Shipping Holdings revenue increased by +44.8% in the fourth quarter of 2024
COSCO Shipping Holdings revenue increased by +44.8% in the fourth quarter of 2024
Shanghai
In the period, the container ships of the Chinese group's fleet transported 6.9 million TEUs (+13.1%). Containers on the Asia-Europe/Med routes fell
Porto Marghera, renewal of concession to Terminal Rinfuse Venezia
Venice
New 25-year contract. Investments of over 53 million euros expected
Carnival Sets New Low Season Quarter Records December-February
Carnival Sets New Low Season Quarter Records December-February
Miami
Positive outlook for the remainder of the 2025 financial year
In the last quarter of 2024, container traffic alone increased in French ports
Paris
Le Aziende informanoSponsored Article
AAL Shipping sceglie il sistema di consulenza marina di ABB per ottimizzare la flotta Super B-Class
Rail Losing Ground in Transalpine Freight Traffic Through Switzerland
Bern
In 2024, trains transported 25.7 million tons of cargo (-3.7%)
CK Hutchison's Port Division revenues grew by 10.8% last year
Hong Kong
In 2024, Hapag-Lloyd revenues increased by +6.5%. Net profit decreased by -18.9%
In 2024, Hapag-Lloyd revenues increased by +6.5%. Net profit decreased by -18.9%
Hamburg
New historical record of containers transported by the fleet
The OPS also serves to charge the batteries of ships while they are in port
The OPS also serves to charge the batteries of ships while they are in port
Brussels
The ferry companies remind us of this by highlighting the need to have an adequate supply of electricity.
The extension of the EU ETS to the maritime transport sector has not brought about significant changes in the shipping market
Brussels
This is stated in a report adopted by the European Commission, which found no evidence of tendencies towards evasion or avoidance of the law
In February, freight traffic in the port of Barcelona decreased by -4.2%
Barcelona
Containers down -4.2% due to -18.8% reduction in transhipped boxes
Complaint filed for fraud and corruption against Bolloré Group
Paris
Allegations relating to activities carried out in the context of logistics and port operations in Africa sold in 2022
US FMC surveys seven major global maritime corridors
Washington
Federal agency threatens to ban Panamanian-flagged ships from US ports
Last year, freight traffic in German ports began to grow again (+2.3%)
Wiesbaden
It is still lower than the pre-Covid level, as is container traffic alone which amounted to 13.3 million TEU (+4.9%)
BIMCO: The application of specific port charges to Chinese ships calling at the US will prove a disaster for the American economy
London
The impact of the proposed measures on China's dominance in shipbuilding is highly uncertain
Federagenti hopes for greater involvement of global financial groups in logistics, ports and infrastructure
Rome
Pessina: necessary to make the leap in quality
Conference in Genoa for the centenary of Ente Bacini
Genoa
The company was established on 19 February 1925
Interporto Bologna Board of Directors Renewed
Bentivoglio
Stefano Caliandro Appointed President. Loss of 1.7 million euros in 2024
NYK invests 76 billion yen in NYK Energy Ocean Corporation
Tokyo
The newco has taken over the activities of ENEOS Ocean
Decarbonisation of maritime transport will be faster in the EU and the US
DHL Acquires CRYOPDP
Bonn/Nashville
The company provides courier services for clinics and healthcare
Over a million to the port companies of Livorno and Piombino to acquire green vehicles
Leghorn
The ranking for admission to the PNRR-Next Gen Eu contributions has been published
COSCO Shipping Development Co.'s container sales increased by +204.1% in 2024
Shanghai
The related turnover increased by +124.0%
The call for funding for the purchase of electric vehicles in the ports of Genoa and Savona-Vado has been published
Genoa
Yang Ming Buys Three New 8,000 TEU Containerships
Keelung
They will be delivered between 2028 and 2029
Construction of a cruise ship for Regent Seven Seas Cruises begins in Marghera
Trieste
Fincantieri will deliver the unit in 2026
Federlogistica establishes operational offices in Spain and Brazil
Genoa
The aim is to go beyond theoretical cooperative relationships
Over a Ton of Cocaine Seized in the Port of Gioia Tauro
Reggio Calabria
If placed on the market it would have generated over 187 million euros
In 2024, the economic results of Interporto Padova reached record values
Padua
Revenues up +17%
Three ceremonies at the Saint-Nazaire shipyard for three new MSC Cruises ships
Geneva
New flagship "MSC World America" delivered
German railway company DB Cargo reduced losses in 2024
Berlin
Revenues down again. -9.0% drop in freight volumes
NovaAlgoma orders second 38,000 dwt cement carrier in China
Lugano
It will be taken over in 2027
Customs agreement between Italy and Brazil to facilitate trade
Brasilia
Mission of the Customs and Monopolies Agency in the South American nation
A team from La Spezia Container Terminal in Rotterdam to test advanced technologies
The Spice
ECT Hutchinson Ports Training Center Visited
The assembly of Genoese freight forwarders on Monday
Genoa
It will be held at the Palazzo della Borsa in Genoa
Assarmatori, in Italy the ferry segment cannot bear the burden of the EU ETS in a very fragile market situation
Brussels
Messina: Protecting shipping from the ideological excesses of the Green Deal
The website of the Port Authority Corps - Coast Guard has been renewed
Rome
It has become a single digital access point to documents and services
In 2024, inland waterway freight transport in Germany increased by +1.2%
Wiesbaden
The volume, at 173.8 million tonnes, is the second lowest since 1990.
APM Terminals Granted Port of New York - New Jersey Concession Renewal
New York
Contract for a period of 33 years. Investments of 500 million dollars are expected
Experimentation of crane automation has begun at the Interporto Padova terminal
Padua
The interport company awarded the "Industria Felix 2025 Award"
Container traffic in the port of Algeciras fell by -17.0% in February
Algeciras
Both import-export volumes and transhipment are decreasing
New cruise company Crescent Seas has been founded in Miami
Miami
The fleet, initially consisting of one ship from Regent Seven Seas Cruises, will grow to five units within the next five years
In 2024, the volume of vehicles transported by Wallenius Wilhelmsen's fleet decreased by -9.7%
Oslo
Traffic down on almost all global routes
SAILING LIST
Visual Sailing List
Departure ports
Arrival ports by:
- alphabetical order
- country
- geographical areas
Agreement between Assoporti and Assologistica and the Florida trade, transport and port authorities
Rome
It was signed today
In April a mission in Albania of The International Propeller Clubs - Italy
Genoa
It will take place on the 9th and 10th in Tirana and Durres
COSCO Shipping Ports revenues rose to a record $1.5 billion in 2024 (+3.3%)
Hong Kong
In the fourth quarter alone, a decrease of -3.0%
SO.RI.MA. (FHP group) granted a concession of an area of 125 thousand square meters in the port of Chioggia
Venice
Investments of 11.5 million euros expected over 25 years
Container traffic in the port of Valencia grew by +15.2% last month
Valencia
The overall volume of goods handled increased by +6.8%
Contship Italia’s intermodal network has been extended to the Gulf Terminal in La Spezia
Melzo
Connections with the inland terminals of Milan, Modena and Padua
The Northern Tyrrhenian Sea Port Authority obtains gender equality certification
Leghorn
It is the first Italian port authority to obtain this recognition
Container traffic growth weakens at ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach
Los Angeles/Long Beach
Last month, increases of +2.6% and +13.4% respectively were recorded
Assarmatori, the Italian government's position on the impact of the EU ETS on shipping and ports is good
Rome
Messina: fully understood the risks and distortions of European climate regulation
PSA Italy's Genoa port terminals awarded anti-corruption certification
Genoa
The UNI EN ISO 37001 standard defines the requirements for an effective anti-corruption management system
Assiterminal presents three projects for the sustainable transition of the Italian port sector
Rome
Work completed on docks 33 and 34 of the port of Civitavecchia
Civitavecchia
50,000 square meters of yards prepared
The completion and doubling of the Pontremolese is the dream-nightmare of the La Spezia port community
The Spice
Fontana: Money is not found when enormous resources are channeled into railway lines of dubious utility
Hanwha acquires 9.9% stake in shipbuilding company Austal
Sydney
Investment worth approximately 116 million US dollars
The European fleet is growing but competing fleets are growing at a faster rate
Brussels
Raptis (European Shipowners): investing ETS revenues in clean shipping technologies and fuels
Trasportounito has confirmed the national halt to the transport of goods
Rome
Proclaimed for the duration of five days from March 31st to April 4th
PORTS
Italian Ports:
Ancona Genoa Ravenna
Augusta Gioia Tauro Salerno
Bari La Spezia Savona
Brindisi Leghorn Taranto
Cagliari Naples Trapani
Carrara Palermo Trieste
Civitavecchia Piombino Venice
Italian Interports: list World Ports: map
DATABASE
ShipownersShipbuilding and Shiprepairing Yards
ForwardersShip Suppliers
Shipping AgentsTruckers
MEETINGS
The assembly of Genoese freight forwarders on Monday
Genoa
It will be held at the Palazzo della Borsa in Genoa
Tomorrow in Naples a conference of studies on the fight against illicit trafficking by sea
Naples
It will be held at the University of "Parthenope"
››› Meetings File
PRESS REVIEW
Damen Mangalia Unionists Protest Friday Against Possible Closure
(The Romania Journal)
Govt. to woo top ten shipping liners in world for Colombo port expansion
(Daily Mirror)
››› Press Review File
FORUM of Shipping
and Logistics
Relazione del presidente Nicola Zaccheo
Roma, 18 settembre 2024
››› File
Container traffic in Hong Kong port increased by +9.1% in February
Hong Kong
However, for the second time in the last 25 years, cargo volume was below one million TEU.
Cargo traffic in Greek ports stable in Q3 2024
Piraeus
The increase in volumes transported on domestic routes has offset the decline in traffic with foreign countries
At the Vado Ligure container terminal a 21,000 teu container ship fully loaded
I go to Liguria
The 400-meter-long Cosco Shipping Nebula has landed
UIR proposes a permanent table for the development of intermodality
Verona
The main task is to build a project financing program.
Restructuring plan approved for Spanish company Armas Trasmediterránea
Las Palmas de Gran Canaria
Creditors' appeal rejected
The decline in cargo traffic at the port of Singapore worsened in February
Singapore
Containerized cargoes amounted to 27.4 million tons (-3.6%)
Accelleron revenue surpassed $1 billion for the first time in 2024
Baden
Net profit up +63.1%
Fincantieri has delivered the new ship Norwegian Aqua to Norwegian Cruise Line
Trieste
It has a gross tonnage of 156,300 tons.
The tender for the first lot of the new electricity distribution network in the port of La Spezia has started
The Spice
Intervention worth 36.9 million euros
In 2024 d'Amico International Shipping recorded a decline in time charter revenues
Luxembourg
-7.6% decline on the previous record year
Global Ports Holding's port terminals handled record cruise traffic in 2024
Istanbul
The company's revenue increased by +21%
In the first two months of 2025, cargo traffic in Russian ports decreased by -5.7%
St. Petersburg
Only import loads are growing
The latest reading of the WTO Goods Trade Barometer shows a variable trend towards good
Geneva
Trasportounito will propose a national haulage ban from March 31st
Rome
Longo: from the Ministry evanescent and contentless answers
The introduction of ESG standards represents a profound transformation for port companies
Rome
Attica Reports Record Revenue and Operating Performance in 2024
Athens
Profits down due to costs of merger with Anek and purchase of emission allowances
Man arrested in investigation into collision between Solong and Stena Immaculate
Southampton
The charge is manslaughter due to gross negligence
Beijing: Measures to revive US shipbuilding industry won't work
Beijing
New duties and tariffs - the government underlines - are harmful for both parties
Messina Gets $50M Funding to Support Full Container Investment
Genoa
Agreement with BPER Banca and Banca Popolare di Sondrio
The tanker Sounion attacked in August in the Red Sea has passed through the Suez Canal
Ismailia
Collision between two ships near the port of Hull
Southampton / Jacksonville / Rotterdam
Fires broke out on both units
- Via Raffaele Paolucci 17r/19r - 16129 Genoa - ITALY
phone: +39.010.2462122, fax: +39.010.2516768, e-mail
VAT number: 03532950106
Press Reg.: nr 33/96 Genoa Court
Editor in chief: Bruno Bellio
No part may be reproduced without the express permission of the publisher
Search on inforMARE Presentation
Feed RSS Advertising spaces

inforMARE in Pdf
Mobile